Businessolver
Businessolver Blog

New Data: Toxic workplaces are winning—for now. 

Benefits pulse June 2026

Sign up for our emails to get the Benefits Pulse, trending blogs, and more delivered to your inbox:

Businessolver profile photo
By Businessolver
 on June 25, 2026
Share:

CEOs love empathy, but not at work. 

Our 11th annual State of Workplace Empathy study is full of paradoxical data. Most notably that CXOs (such as CEOs, CFOs, CHROs, and CTOs) who say their culture is toxic are 2X more likely to also report significant financial growth for their organizations.  

Yikes.  

If that wasn’t enough to raise some eyebrows, those same CXOs also rate themselves and their companies higher in empathy compared to their peers in non-toxic companies. 

We’ve been reporting on this paradox for a while. What gives?  

The CEO optimism bubble persists 

We asked Jon Shanahan, Businessolver’s CEO, for his thoughts on this:  

“In eleven years of studying empathy, we’ve never seen results like these. The numbers don’t add up. But then again, given the level of volatility and polarization we’re living in today, maybe the paradoxical findings in this year’s report are exactly the right reflection of a world in flux.” 

Keep reading: Jon says more in his opening letter in the State of Workplace Empathy report.  

But this can’t go on forever…right?  

We’d like to say no, but the empathy gap between the c-suite and employees has persisted for a while. 

But it’s not without consequences. 

  • 66% of employees say they’ll leave for a more empathetic workplace. Even if that means taking up to a 20% pay cut. Yeah, it’s that serious.  
  • No empathy = more burnout. Employees in unempathetic workplaces are more likely to report experiencing more burnout, anxiety, and depression in the past year.  
  • CXOs aren’t having a good culture experience, either. 73% in toxic cultures say they feel intimidated by their coworkers. 

We’re just barely scratching the surface, though.  

What if we called it a “business continuity risk”? 

Last year, we calculated an estimated $180B at risk in attrition alone if workplace culture and C-suite perspectives don’t change.  

Are CXOs finally starting to see what’s on the horizon? Signs point to “yes.” 

SOWE report graph with data points

We’re not the only ones forecasting the risk that lies ahead: 

  • Gallup finds that only 20% of employees, globally, are engaged at work, putting up to $438B in lost productivity at risk. 
  • McKinsey has a more optimistic outlook, putting healthy organizations ahead, driving up to 3X more ROI compared to performance at unhealthy organizations.

It’s a numbers game, and the odds aren’t in toxic CXOs’ favor for much longer. Read our full findings in this year’s data.

Other workforce wellness conversations we’re listening to: